We The People USA

Citizens Dedicated To Preserving Our Constitutional Republic

Supreme Court Ruling Knocks Down Pelosi’s Impeachment Demands “

The Supreme Court has already pointed out that the Constitution doesn’t require the “additional procedural requirements” that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is apparently demanding from the Senate before it tries the impeachment of President Trump.

Pelosi (D-Calif.) has stated that she intends to withhold the articles of impeachment from the Senate until the upper chamber agrees to terms she has set forth.

But in the 1993 ruling Nixon v. United States, the Court ruled that “additional procedural requirements” on the Senate are “inconsistent with the three express limitations” that the Constitution has set on the Senate for trying impeachments in its associated Clause.

In other words, they aren’t required by the Constitution.

Despite the case’s name, the 1993 ruling doesn’t have anything to do with the impeachment of Richard Nixon but revolved around the impeachment of US District Court Chief Judge Walter Nixon, who refused to resign after being convicted of perjury charges.

Nixon had suggested that because a Senate committee – and not the full Senate – had received the evidence, which was then reported to the full Senate, the impeachment was unconstitutional.

In response, the Supreme Court said the Constitution gave broad discretion to the Senate in how it handled impeachments, pointing out that the Constitution imposed no such requirements on the Senate.

The court even refrained from reviewing Nixon’s impeachment due to this discretion afforded to the Senate, another branch of government, as part of the separation of powers.

…The existence of the three very specific requirements that the Clause’s second and third sentences do impose – that the Senate’s Members must be under oath or affirmation, that a two-thirds vote is required to convict, and that the Chief Justice presides when the President is tried – the precise nature of which suggests that the Framers did not intend to impose additional limitations on the form of the Senate proceedings.

The Clause’s first sentence must instead be read as a grant of authority to the Senate to determine whether an individual should be acquitted or convicted, and the commonsense and dictionary meanings of the word “sole” indicate that this authority is reposed in the Senate alone.

…Requiring impeachment only by the full Senate is unnatural, and would impose on the Senate additional procedural requirements that would be inconsistent with the three express limitations that the Clause sets out.

Thus it can also be argued that Pelosi is in no position to dictate terms with the Senate before sending over articles of impeachment because the Constitution imposes no such requirement outside of the three limitations the Constitution does enforce on the Senate.

And it can be argued that the Senate is free to take up the case once the House vote is officially recorded.

This argument is also bolstered by the Constitution stating that the “Senate shall have the sole Power to try all Impeachments,” suggesting that Pelosi has no say in the matter as House Speaker because the Senate has broad discretion:

The Senate shall have the sole Power to try all Impeachments. When sitting for that Purpose, they shall be on Oath or Affirmation. When the President of the United States is tried, the Chief Justice shall preside: And no Person shall be convicted without the Concurrence of two thirds of the Members present.

So, in closing this, I say to Pelosi...... send it or toss it in the trash, and leave office with the rest of your so called "Party"......And keep you and your so called "Party's" big mouth shut.... You Lost Yet Again...

Views: 3

Comment

You need to be a member of We The People USA to add comments!

Join We The People USA

Blog Posts

Another one bites the dust......

Posted by Hoffi Gwlithlys on January 13, 2020 at 10:25am 0 Comments

DES MOINES, Iowa -- Democrat Cory Booker dropped out of the presidential race Monday, ending a campaign whose message of unity and love failed to resonate in a political era marked by chaos and anxiety.

New Jersey 101.5's Eric Scott…

Continue

THE POTUS IS COMIMG!!!!!! THE POTUS IS COMING...LET"S MAKE NJ CRANBERRY RED!!!!

Posted by Hoffi Gwlithlys on January 7, 2020 at 12:37pm 0 Comments

January 28, 2020... the night that turns NJ CRANBERRY RED... President Trump has scheduled a rally at the Wildwood Convention Center.  For me, this is a most epic event for NJ Conservatives and the State GOP. 

Despite the Radical Liberal…

Continue

As this day sees the sunet, The Spirit of it should never die......

Posted by Hoffi Gwlithlys on December 25, 2019 at 5:34pm 0 Comments

In my house, the festivities and fuss has come to a gentle end after completing the exchanges of gifts, and a meal together as a family and a moment of calm before I head out tonight to protect and serve. We never take a day or a breath for…

Continue

Supreme Court Ruling Knocks Down Pelosi’s Impeachment Demands “

Posted by Hoffi Gwlithlys on December 20, 2019 at 2:00pm 0 Comments

The Supreme Court has already pointed out that the Constitution doesn’t require the “additional procedural requirements” that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is apparently demanding from the Senate before it tries the impeachment of President…

Continue

NJ Dem to join makeing NJ Cranberry Red?!!!! One of hope, yet of Caution

Posted by Hoffi Gwlithlys on December 14, 2019 at 9:00pm 0 Comments

Rep. Jeff Van Drew, D-NJ., met with President Trump Friday to discuss going across party lines and joining the Republican Party- this…

Continue

Posted by Hoffi Gwlithlys on November 14, 2019 at 7:06am 0 Comments

IT"S LOONET TUNE TIME!!I A New Place to have you ROFL!!!!!

Posted by Hoffi Gwlithlys on November 14, 2019 at 7:05am 0 Comments

A weekly all day Saturday fun event beginning  this November 15  is for All members to show off their humor, pics, meme's and other jocularity comments to the issues at hand.

In addition,and shall will be carefully monitored; we…

Continue

Anerican's Still winning.....It's about time!!!

Posted by Hoffi Gwlithlys on November 14, 2019 at 5:15am 0 Comments

Republicans Tout Incredible Judicial Confirmation Numbers



  • November 12, 2019
  • President Donald J. Trump is nominating judges to the federal bench at an astonishing pace.…

Continue

Support WTPUSA

Badge

Loading…

Contact Congress

Online Magazines

Accuracy In Media
American Spectator
American Thinker
American Conservative
Amer Conservative Daily
The American Prospect
Atlanta Const Journal
The Atlantic Monthly
Boston Review
Blacklisted News
The Bulletin
Canada Free Press
Capitalism Magazine
Chronicles Magazine
City Journal
CNS News
CNIN Truth
Conservative Economist
Consortium News
Commentary Magazine
The Conservative Edge
Conservative Outpost
Corruption Chronicals (JW)
The Corzine Times
CounterPunch
The Daily Caller
Daily Mail UK
Deep Journal
Digital Journal
Dissent Magazine
The Economist
Examiner
Florida Pundit
Foreign Affairs
Foreign Policy
The Freemen Institute
The Gouverneur Times NY
The Guardian UK
The Foundry (Heritage)
Free Market News
FrontPage Magazine
Gateway Pundit
The Guardian UK
The Globalist
Harper's Magazine
Harvard Inter Review
The Hill
Human Events
In These Times
The Land of the Free
Liberty Unbound
Mission America
Mother Jones
Monthly Review
The Nation
National Interest
National Ledger
National Review
New Internationalist
The New American
The New Ledger
New Left Review
New Media Journal
News Hounds
Newstin
The New Republic
News Busters
News Fifty
NewsMax
Newsweek
News Daily
News With Views
Online Journal
Oohja.com
The Palestine Chronicle
Planet Daily
Policy Review
Poligazette
Politics Daily
The Post Chronicle
Pravda
The Progressive
Reality Check
The Real News Network
Reason
Real Clear Markets
Real Clear Politics
Red Pepper
Roll Call
Russia Today
Salon
Slate
Spectator Magazine
Spiked
Telegraph UK
Time
Toward Freedom
Townhall
U.S. News & World Report
Utne Reader
Wall Street Journal Magazine
Washington Examiner
The Washington Independent
Washington Monthly
The Weekly Standard
World Net Daily
World Magazine
World Press Review
World Reports
World Tribune
Vanity Fair

© 2020   Created by WTPUSA.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service